Alligator Point Beach Rentals
Vacation Homes along the Forgotten Coast at Alligator Point, Bald Point, Shell Point, and Panacea
Featured Locations
All within an hour of Tallahassee, our vacation homes are in small, coastal communities along Highway 98. All four locations provide peaceful atmospheres, proximity to the Gulf, and beautiful surroundings.
Alligator Point/Bald Point
Named for the shape of the Point, not the abundance of alligators, Alligator Point is tucked away along the beautiful Forgotten Coast. This quiet coastal community offers everything you love about Old Florida: peaceful beaches, incredible sunsets, abundant wildlife, and the chance to slow down and enjoy the simple things in life. Several public beach access points and boat ramps are available at the Point with a marina at one end and Bald Point State Park at the other. Whether you choose a home on the bay or the Gulf, Alligator Point is a place to slow down and enjoy the beauty and nature in the area. Discover why Alligator Point is one of north Florida’s best-kept secrets!
Shell Point
A nature lover’s paradise, Shell Point is a charming waterfront community in Wakulla County, just south of Tallahassee. Known for its laid-back atmosphere, scenic waterways, and beautiful coastal views, Shell Point is a wonderful destination for visitors looking to escape the crowds. Spend your days boating, fishing, kayaking, or exploring the nearby beaches and natural areas, then unwind with a spectacular sunset over the water. With its quiet surroundings and easy access to local seafood restaurants, marinas, and the nearby communities of Panacea and St. Marks, Shell Point offers the perfect blend of outdoor adventure and peaceful relaxation.
Panacea
Nestled along Florida’s scenic Gulf Coast, Panacea is a charming fishing village known for its Old Florida character, abundant wildlife, and laid-back coastal lifestyle. Located about 45 minutes south of Tallahassee, Panacea favorite for visitors who love boating, fishing, kayaking, and exploring the natural beauty of the Gulf. Spend your days discovering the area’s beautiful waterways, visiting local seafood restaurants, or exploring nearby natural treasures like the St. Marks National Wildlife Refuge and Ochlockonee River State Park. With its friendly local atmosphere, and easy access to some of Florida’s most peaceful coastal spots, Panacea offers a refreshing escape from crowded tourist destinations.
St. Teresa Beach
St. Teresa is a peaceful coastal community known for its quiet beaches, waterfront homes, and unspoiled natural beauty. An hour south of Tallahassee, St. Teresa Beach offers a relaxing escape from the crowds where visitors can spend their days fishing, boating, kayaking, or simply enjoying the sunshine and salty Gulf breezes. With beautiful sunsets and easy access to nearby coastal communities like Panacea and Alligator Point, St. Teresa is an ideal destination for travelers seeking a slower pace of life. Nature lovers will appreciate the area’s abundant wildlife and proximity to the scenic landscapes of Florida’s coast, while those looking to unwind can enjoy peaceful mornings, waterfront relaxation, and star-filled evenings.
What our guests have to say:
“Absolutely loved our stay here at the Professor’s Fish House. This place had everything you needed! Set up perfectly so you can spend time relaxing and not worrying about all the little things! Thank you for sharing your beautiful home with us!!! We can’t wait to come back!”
Barbara F.
“Calyn and the management team were wonderful. They went above and beyond. So accommodating and courteous. The house [Lookout Point] was thoughtfully furnished and perfect for our scalloping adventure! We will be returning.”
Justin M.
“We have rented the same place several times. The place is always spotless, and the communication with the host is excellent! Will stay here again!”
Jason C.
“Nothing improves mental health and pleasure in life than a wonderful relaxing stay on a real beach. No crowds, just the waves, the sand and you. Add some great seafood and heaven must be close by. Dolphin, deer, and eagles top it off. The owner and staff are wonderful.”
Less B.
“This place was just as I had dreamed it would be and more! The views were incredible. The dock was the cherry on top and provided us a safe place to tie the boat to. Redfish were caught, cleaned, and cooked onsite which made it all easy-peazy!! Whatever else we needed that wasn’t caught was within walking distance at My Way Seafood; Ike and his momma Debby have been our family’s “go to” for over 30 years! If you don’t find it there, you can always grab some tasty dips or other seafood from Mineral Springs down the road! Panacea is true to its name and the home is too. We will most definitely be back!”
Kim B.
Featured Homes
Whether you’re here for a weekend, a week, or a month, our homes have something for every kind of traveler.
Dolphin Point- Shell Point, FL
Experience the beauty of Florida’s Forgotten Coast at this extraordinary Gulf-front retreat in Shell Point. Completely renovated from top to bottom, this stunning four-bedroom, four-bathroom home blends coastal luxury with the laid-back charm of waterfront living. With panoramic water views and a new dock on the bay side, this is a one-of-a-kind escape for families and friends looking to experience the best of the Gulf Coast.
Coastal Cottage- Panacea, FL
A nature lover’s paradise, the Coastal Cottage has it all! Nestled on the edge of Dickerson Bay, it’s located in a gated community with a pool, a pool house, a gazebo and a fishing pier. This stylish circular-shaped home comes with an open floor plan, lots of windows and natural light, many new upgrades, and the views are absolutely phenomenal! The home is within walking distance to waterfront restaurants and the Gulf Specimen Aquarium.
Toes in the Sand- Alligator Point, FL
This Cape Code style beauty will make you fall in love with the Forgotten Coast! Watch dolphins jump outside your window in this spacious 3/2 with over 2,000 square feet. There is plenty of room to spread out, relax, and soak up the sun. Well-appointed kitchen and a screened in back porch that pairs perfectly with your margarita. Residential elevator can help you go to and from the carport to the main level.
Bill’s Bay Breeze- Alligator Point, FL
The perfect spot for a family vacation or a weekend getaway! The screened-in back porch is relaxing, with waterfront views of the bay and the wildlife. This house sleeps 8 and is roughly 10 houses down from Public Beach Access on Alligator Point. You can also enjoy Alligator Point’s Marina right down the road where you can launch your boat to enjoy a day of fishing.
Our Forgotten Coast Locations
Our vacation homes are along the Forgotten Coast at Alligator Point, Shell Point, St. Teresa, Panacea, and Bald Point.
